PrimeInvestor will make you a better investor!
Just follow our recommendations.
Please note: We are a SEBI registered Research Analyst. Not a FinFluencer.
Nifty 50 prev close: 25250.1 2.12%
PrimeInvestor investment indicator is a tool that tells you whether it is a good time to invest in the market currently. It is available only to PrimeInvestor subscribers and trial users.
Please subscribe or register for a free trial to access.
The investment action suggested by the Nifty VMI has been derived based on analysing over 20 years’ worth of data on the Nifty PE ratio, the Nifty PB ratio and different momentum indicators of the Nifty 50 index.
Do note that the indicators above are all based on the Nifty PE ratio and not based on the broad market. Always consider your risk level and timeframe before making any investment. For more detail on how to read the three indicators above, please go here.
The Nifty VMI is an extremely useful market mood and investment indicator. However, there are a few points to note:
Price earnings ratio (PE ratio) is the rupee value that you are willing to pay for every rupee of earnings of a company.
When the price of a stock is divided by the per share earnings of a company, you get the PE ratio. The same when applied to the Nifty 50 stocks becomes the index’ PE ratio.
The PE ratio is considered a key valuation metric to know how expensive a stock is in relation to its peers. Since the Nifty 50 is a bellwether index, the Nifty PE is used as a gauge to know if markets are expensive or cheap.
What you find above is a Nifty PE Ratio chart which gives a complete history of this critical indicator since 2000. According to the NSE website, the Nifty 50 PE ratio is calculated as follows:
Formula: Index market capitalization / Gross earnings
While the Nifty PE ratio is a good gauge for whether markets are too expensive to enter, there are two aspects to why it becomes important to take other fundamental metrics and valuations into consideration in addition to the Nifty PE ratio for investment decisions.
#1 PE can alter based on sector composition
When it comes to valuing companies, all sectors are not born equal. Markets assign premium valuations to sectors seen to have predictable earnings prospects and high shareholder returns such as FMCGs, IT and retail banks. Sectors with cyclical fortunes such as oil and gas, metals and mining and commodities usually trade at low PEs, even in good times.
Now, thanks to active index management, the Nifty 50’s sectoral composition tends to change quite drastically over time. This makes PE comparisons over time tricky. For example, when the index is overweight on cyclicals such as oil and gas, construction or metals, the Nifty PE may seem lower than when the index is dominated by FMCG, IT or financial services which traditionally command a premium. Hence, taking cognizance of sectoral changes in the index is important.
#2 The denominator can result in conflicting signals
When assessing a stock for investment, we don’t look at its PE in isolation but also at trends in earnings in recent years, to see if the valuation is off a low base or a high one. For a company that is just turning around from losses to profits, for instance, a high PE may be irrelevant. The same logic applies to the index too. The PE for the Nifty50 needs to be interpreted based on whether the companies in it are coming off a period of high or low earnings growth. When the Indian market peaked out at a Nifty PE ratio of over 28 times in January 2008 Nifty companies had managed an earnings growth of 21 per cent in the preceding five years. However, for the same PE, if the earnings growth of Nifty companies is lacklustre, then may have conflicting views. If you’re a pessimist, you can cite this as evidence that the bull market in the last five years has little basis in fundamentals. But if you’re an optimist, you can also believe that with mean reversion, the earnings are likely to rebound at some time.
This article by Aswath Damodaran, Professor at the Stern School of Business at New York University, will clearly bring out the limitations of PE as a valuation assessment metric. He also brings out the dichotomy of a higher PE ratio for cash rich companies and a lower PE ratio of debt laden companies and why this can lead to misinterpretation. You can also read our article on whether you should dynamically alter your asset allocation based on the Nifty PE.