Indexation benefit does not apply for investments made from April 1, 2023 onwards. You can read all about the tax change for mutual funds that kicked in on April 1, 2023, in our article, ‘Tax changes in mutual funds: How to manage your investments now‘
If there is one thing that has dominated the new fund offer space, and your collective interest, it is target maturity funds. Over the past year, the debt market has dealt with a swift rise in interest rates and we have issued multiple strategies to alert you on opportunities that presented themselves.
In our previous strategy recommendations, we had mentioned that for those who have a short-term timeframe and want to lock into yields, target maturity funds are a good option. In this strategy, we want to specifically alert you on the yield opportunity in short-term debt, through target maturity funds for three reasons:
- The upward movement in the short-term yields, owing to a clutch of reasons
- The ability to lock into prevailing yields with target maturity funds, which offers more predictable returns and time frame
- The current timing (before end of FY-23) which offers an additional year of indexation benefits, for a shorter-term timeframe – thus providing superior tax efficiency
Short-term opportunity
Let’s quickly explain with why debt markets have opened up several opportunities in the past few months. For a prolonged period, interest rates were at all-time lows, as a measure to encourage growth and lending during the pandemic. This came after a period where rates remained stagnant.
We are, therefore, seeing a persistent cycle of rising rates after a gap of several years and a shift in the rate cycle always opens up different opportunities. Not just that, it is at a time when central banks around the world are similarly dealing with spiralling inflation and hiking rates. Remember that yields move both in anticipation of rate action by central banks as well as the actual action. Therefore, new developments – such as a suddenly higher inflation print, which we saw in January, or commentary by the US Fed – can cause changes in yields.
This also means that we need to be on our toes to spot the different strategies that could help better returns, since it’s not often that debt markets throw up an array of opportunities!
Now, yield movements in the shorter end of the tenor range have been far sharper than the longer end. See the chart below, sourced from Care Ratings. It shows the yield curve (yields mapped across different tenors) in three different months. As you will see, the yield difference between the short- and long-term periods has narrowed by February 2023 compared to August 2022.
A key factor, of course, is that the interest rate hikes that began last year have reflected far quicker in the short-term yields. Longer-term debt tends to react earlier to rate changes, and 10-year bond yields started factoring in rate hikes well ahead of the actual hikes. For the past few months, the long-term yields have also stayed put as expectations are largely built in.
But apart from this, another key factor that has sent short-term yields higher is liquidity. Along with rate hikes, the Reserve Bank also began to reduce the liquidity in the system – both to normalise after the Covid-driven excess, and to also enable pass-through of rate action. Therefore, from a heavy surplus, liquidity has now moved to the neutral zone especially in recent months. System liquidity has a bigger impact on the shorter-tenor yields than longer-tenor which is more influenced by inflation, government borrowings, and so on. Other smaller factors that could be working at this time include money outflow to meet advance tax payments that can keep yields higher.
Which target maturity funds
We have specifically picked target maturity funds to play this specific opportunity in short-term yields for a few reasons:
- One, these funds allow locking into current yields – similar to getting in on fixed deposits when rates are attractive.
- The indexation benefit that these funds provide make them superior to FDs, at a time when FDs are also offering high interest rates.
- These funds also offer better predictability in terms of returns (please note that this does not necessarily mean superior returns) and also the average maturity, than other debt fund categories.
The target maturity funds currently available span a wide maturity range from 2023 to 2036. In this, we think the 2025, 2026 and 2027 maturities offer the best yield trade off at present. Yields on the longer maturity funds are similar or even lower than the yields in these three buckets.
The table below shows the list of target maturity funds we are recommending. We have gone with funds for which we data on portfolio yields, as well as considered AUMs and expense ratios.
Note the following:
- Choose funds based on your timeframe. This call is primarily a buy and hold call. Kindly do not compare it with the longer duration funds we have recommended earlier for capital appreciation when rates fall.
- Any combination is fine: You can invest in any or a combination of these fund/funds. You will need to hold the fund to maturity to earn returns close to the yields. There may be price volatility in the interim, but the idea is not to exit before maturity.
- Indexation alert: If you are investing in the funds, make sure you do so before March 31st in order to earn an extra year's indexation benefits. But do note that the 2025 funds will not come with indexation benefits as the holding period is less than 3 years.
- Tracking error not known: We do not know the tracking error for these funds. For one, we don’t have underlying index data (not available) to calculate tracking. Secondly, most funds are new and have limited performance history. We have mostly opted for larger-sized funds in the hope that these would find it easier to keep errors low.
- Yields mentioned not the latest: The yields above are not current yields. Current yields are marginally lower; the Bharat Bond 2025, for example, is 7.65% now while the Axis 2027 SDL fund is at 7.66%. Most AMCs do not offer current yield data.
Suitability and your other debt funds
The question that most of you would ask is if you should hang on to your current debt funds or exit and reinvest in these target maturity funds.
The answer is - do not exit from your current holdings 😊
This opportunity to get into superior yields offered by target maturity funds is suitable in the following circumstances:
- You have fresh surplus to invest and you’re looking for opportunities to earn better returns in debt.
- You’re attracted by high interest rates bank FDs are currently willing to pay out and you’re wondering if you should go for them instead of debt funds.
- You have a specific timeframe for investment and you’re looking for low-risk options that are still decent in terms of returns.
- You’re keen on adding target maturity funds to your portfolio and unsure on which one to go for.
These funds can be avoided when you’re simply using debt funds as part of the debt allocation in your portfolio. Here, your existing debt funds will continue to be eminently suitable; yields across debt funds have markedly gone up over the past 6-8 months.
It is not that good returns lie in target maturity funds alone – debt funds from other categories are also perfectly capable of delivering well! And in fact, in the event of a rate fall, medium duration funds (apart from long duration ones) can benefit well from a price rally, thus providing capital appreciation, apart from the coupon income. It is simply the return predictability of target maturity funds that makes them more suitable for specific goals (listed above). With other active debt funds, the active management of the portfolio can keep the returns and maturity a moving target.
To sum up, retain existing investments in your debt funds and don’t exit unless they are below-average performers. Use our MF Review Tool to know if your fund is a Sell. Invest any such exited money or fresh sums in the strategy explained here.
General disclosures & disclaimers
29 thoughts on “Debt funds for double indexation and high returns”
I invested in target maturity fund last yr at yield around 6.2% naturing in 2027,after 1 yr return has creeped upto 2.5%.What’s gone wrong.Will I get around 6% if I hold till maturity?
Nothing is wrong 🙂 TMFs do not generate linear returns. TMF returns will see impact from bond prices changes; volatility will reduce the closer it gets to the maturity date. If you hold till maturity, you will earn close to the yields at the time of entry (accounting for expenses & tracking error) – thanks, Bhavana
Can some of these fund be looked at?
Bandhan CRISIL IBX Gilt June 2027 Index Fund
ICICI Pru Nifty PSU Bond Plus SDL Sep 2027 40:60 Index Fund
Tata Nifty SDL Plus AAA PSU Bond Dec 2027 60:40 Index Fund
Bandhan CRISIL IBX Gilt April 2028 Index Fund
DSP Nifty SDL Plus G-Sec Jun 2028 30:70 Index Fund
We wouldn’t go for the 2028 funds at present – the yields are marginally lower or the same as the 2027 funds, and so make lesser of an investing argument. You can go for the ICICI or Tata SDL funds mentioned if you wish to; our recommendations were based on both yields as well as AUM & expenses. Avoid the gilt-only 2027 fund as yields are lower than SDL/PSU based funds. – thanks, Bhavana
how about Gilt Funds which match the duration (3-6 years) compared to TMF?
No, the point in TMFs is that you lock into both yield and duration. Gilt funds will not maintain current duration and will change it based on rate cycle direction. Returns will depend on what these changes are and the timing of it. So the current portfolio yields will be very different from the returns the fund can generate. – thanks, Bhavana
Understood, but If I want to hold the fund beyond 2027, then wouldn’t Gilt be better than TMF of 2027. Any Gilt Funds you recommend? How about SBI and Bandhan?
In this, you need to weigh maturity versus yield. There are multiple factors that go into this; for example, longer maturities, theoretically, need to compensate for the risk of holding loner and therefore should have higher yields. So holding the TMF for longer maturities when yields are not attractive enough for it is avoidable. – thanks, Bhavana
Indexation wouldn’t apply for 2025 target fund if investing now since its less than 36 months right?
Yes…sorry about that, it was an error on our part. We have both updated the post and sent an email clarification alert. However, the yield on the 2025 TMF is still attractive even without indexation, so if it meets your timeframe, it is still good to go for. – thanks, Bhavana
How are you saying that the indexation benefit is there for 2025 maturity funds. For Debt funds long term is considered as 3+ years, then by that if someone invests now in March 2023 then to qualify for indexation benefits the fund should terminate on or after March 2026 or later. So investing in any 2025 series fund will not yield the desired indexation benefits. What am i missing ?
Sorry about that, it was an error on our part. We have both updated the post and sent an email clarification alert. However, the yield on the 2025 TMF is still attractive even without indexation, so if it meets your timeframe, it is still good to go for. – thanks, Bhavana
Hi Madam,
Good analysis!
As short terms yields look good, debt is becoming attractive and beats FD returns.
Shall i keep invested in the short term funds in our recommendation category too?
Thank you for recommending.
Yes, please remain invested in short-term funds you already hold. Use these TMFs only if any of the scenarios mentioned in the post apply to you. – thanks, Bhavana
Could you please give us returns based ôn indexation .cosider some assumption on cost of living. This will give an idea on the returns say for 3 year and 5 year periods
Good one Mam, what exactly does DOUBLE INDEXATION Mean? And if someone buys a bond in March 2023 and redeems in the end in 2025, does it still gets counted as HELD for 3 years?
If you invest before March 31st, you get an extra indexation year. It’s popularly called ‘double indexation’ :). This will apply for the 2026 and onwards TMFs recommended above. – thanks, Bhavana
If one has a fresh surplus but no specific timeframe for investment, should they go for a TM fund or an actively managed one?
In such a case, you can opt for short duration funds, instead of target maturity funds. Please check Prime Funds and pick from the Debt Short Term 1.5-3 years set. – thanks, Bhavana
Thanks for another well timed article.
Will Bharat bond 2025 fund be treated as LTCG when it matures in April 25, if it is bought before 31st March? It actually completes only 2.1 years by then and not 3 years, hence the confusion.
No, it won’t. We’ve updated the post to clarify. However, the yields as such are still attractive for the timeframe and will still be a good option even without indexation. – thanks, Bhavana
Comments are closed.