Many equity investors in India have now lived through more than one market cycle. This means that, when stock prices fall off a cliff as they have recently, such investors do not panic and desperately sell everything they own. Instead, they look at bear phases as opportunities to buy quality stocks for their long-term portfolio.
But even for such seasoned and sensible investors, knowing when to buy is not easy. You could end up deploying a substantial portion of your idle cash after a big fall, only to see even steeper falls ahead. Folks who waited for a 15% fall in the index from its peak to begin their buying at Nifty levels of 15800, for instance, have found the index tumbling another 400-500 points in short order with further damage looking likely.
Yes, both a fundamental idea of where Nifty valuations should stand based on historical averages and a grip on key technical supports can help you time your buys better. These two articles we published earlier, on the Nifty 50 (and we periodically update the Nifty 50 technical outlook) and on market corrections offer indicative Nifty levels at which markets could bottom.
But then, when bear markets enter their end-game, all rationality usually flies out the window.
Waiting for Capitulation
Capitulation marks the end phase that puts a full stop to a bear market and lays the foundation for the next bull phase.
Capitulation is a phase when the sentiment turns so negative that the bellwether indices, stock prices and stock valuations plunge to levels which fundamental analysts didn’t even imagine! When Warren Buffett asks you to ‘buy when there’s blood on the Street’, it is the capitulation phase he’s referring to.
Investors who have lived through the vicious bear markets of September 2001, October 2008 or March 2009, will tell you that stocks bought during such capitulation phases are today the biggest wealth creators in their equity portfolio!
So, assuming you’ve been selectively nibbling at stocks or equity funds in the last few months and are waiting for the end-game, how do you identify the capitulation phase if and when it arrives?
When markets capitulated
Looking back at India’s stock market history with the benefit of hindsight, there were four big capitulation phases when equity sentiment, along with stock prices, hit rock-bottom.
September 21 2001: A market reeling from the dotcom bubble burst saw the Nifty 50 hit a low of 849 points on September 21 2001, after the 9/11 WTC attacks in the US fanned fears of World War III. From the dotcom peak of over 1800 points in February 2000, the Nifty crashed 53% before it made a bottom in September 2001.
October 27 2008: The implosion in global growth in the aftermath of the US housing crisis, caused the Nifty 50 to crash from a high of over 6350 points in January 2008 to a low of 2252 points in October 2008. October 27 2008 marked the bottom of this bear phase, the markets falling 2.31% on that day.
March 6 2009: After charting a weak recovery to over 3000 levels from the GFC crash, the Nifty 50 sank back to 2539 levels.
March 23/24 2020: The realisation that Covid was attaining global proportions as a pandemic, with unknown implications for the economy, employment and public health, saw the Nifty crash to 7515 points and making a bottom 40% below its high of over 12300 points in mid-January 2020.
The above capitulation phases are easy to spot with the benefit of hindsight. But how do you spot capitulation, when you’re living through it? We studied the four instances above to arrive at the following five signs.
Long drawn-out and brutal
Capitulation phases in the stock markets seldom get done quickly and sharply, like getting your wisdom teeth pulled. Instead, they tend to arrive after long-drawn pain that tests your patience much like a migraine headache.
Investors usually have to endure many months of losses and uncertainty about the economy and earnings, before a market correction gives way to full-blown capitulation. In 2001, investors had to withstand nearly 19 months of choppy market action during which the economic commentary was all doom and gloom, before the selling climaxed on September 28 2001 and the markets bottomed out to offer the buying opportunity of a lifetime.
In 2008, investors had to live through 10 months of apocalyptic predictions between January and October, before the capitulation phase arrived on October 27 2008. The relief rally that followed also proved short-lived, and it took a second big dip in early March 2009 to put the full stop to this bear market.
The most recent capitulation phase in March 2020 came swiftly, with barely three months elapsing between market highs of January 2020 and the out-and-out panic triggered by the onset of Covid in March 2020. But the fall in stock prices on this occasion was brutal, as even quality stocks tanked 40-50% within a few days.
Given that every previous capitulation phase in the Indian markets has either taken 10-18 months to play out or has culminated with a 40-50% decline in the bellwether indices, we do seem to be some way away from a capitulation phase in the current context. Today, the Nifty 50 is about 8 months away from the recent high of over 18600 points. But it has corrected just 16% from its highs. A capitulation phase may require one or many more legs of sharp falls before the bears give up.
Dwindling retail flows
It is usually a sure-fire sign of a market bubble when retail investors are enthusiastically boarding the equity bandwagon. The recent bull phase between March 2020 and October 2021 had all the hallmarks of such a bubble, with demat accounts doubling and retail flows not only into MFs but also into IPOs, smallcases, and F&O hitting new highs.
A capitulation phase requires the opposite. It is when newbie retail investors see their 1- and 3-year returns sink into red, sell equities in fear and flee to the safe haven of FDs, that bear markets tend to officially end.
In 2008, net flows into equity MFs had turned negative (more redemptions than purchases) in the crucial months of September/October 2008 with the total flows into equity funds for January-October 2008 falling nearly 80% year on year to Rs 1926 crore.
Given that there are more seasoned MF investors this time around and that SIPs are the favoured route to investing, the fall in retail MF flows may not be as sharp. But so far there are hardly any signs of retail investors developing cold feet, as net monthly inflows into equity MFs have been holding up in the Rs 18000 crore to Rs 19000 crore range, quite high by historical standards.
The only sign of retail investors starting to worry is in the decline in pace of new SIP registrations last month. A fall of at least 25-30% from these levels may be in order before one can call a capitulation phase in the current market. One-year equity fund returns have only recently turned negative while 3-year returns are in the double digits still.
If bear markets can be tough on index names, they can be brutal for the less-known names in the market. Small-cap stocks usually feature more retail shareholders than institutions and have patchy market liquidity. When markets crash, seasoned investors and institutions tend to look for bottom-fishing opportunities in bluechip names first, before getting down to the broader market. These two factors usually lead to small-caps suffering far more widespread and sharper damage than large or mid-cap stocks when the capitulation phase arrives.
One way to assess how the long tail of the market is faring versus the top 100 names is to check the returns on the Nifty500 index vis a vis the Nifty50. In the 2008 market crash, while the Nifty50 lost 64% from peak to trough, the Nifty500 melted down by nearly 70%. In 2001, the Nifty50 fell 53% while the Nifty500 saw 70% of its peak value wiped out.
In the current correction, many small-cap names in commodities, chemicals et al have suffered a rout. But the rout isn’t widespread yet with many small-caps also trading at 20 plus PEs. While the Nifty50 has lost 16% so far, the Nifty500 has declined about 18% from its October 2021 peak. Watch for a widening gap between the two, to gauge whether we’re near capitulation.
The fear gauge
Index providers offer us a handy tool to gauge if markets, on any given day, are in the grip of euphoria or paranoia. The India VIX, or Volatility Index, disseminated by NSE is deemed the fear gauge for Indian markets.
This index captures the annualised volatility expected by options traders in the market over the next 30 trading days. So, a VIX of 21 indicates that traders expect the Nifty50 to move at an annualised rate of 21% in the next month. (More on the workings of the VIX)
While the India VIX has tended to trade in the 15 to 30 range in normal times, periods of high fear in the market have seen it shoot above 70. When selling climaxed in end-October 2008, the India VIX which was trading at 30-40 levels at the beginning of the month, shot up to over 80 to peak at 90. The VIX similarly shot up over 70 and hit 86 on March 25, 2020 the nadir of the recent bear market. The India VIX is currently at a sanguine 21, indicating a lack of panic in the markets.
Advances to declines
Whenever the Nifty dips, have you been scouting hard for bargain hunting opportunities? Well, as long as many investors are doing this, we are unlikely to get to a capitulation phase.
Capitulation sets in when even the most bullish and long-term oriented investors after buying into successive dips, either get tired of further losses or run out of cash. At that point, they stop buying and simply decide to wait it out.
The best way to gauge if a majority of investors have given up on the markets is to check the market’s advances-to-declines ratio. If a majority of listed stocks are awash in a sea of red submerging the few islands of green, that’s a sign of a bear market nearing its end-game.
The NSE offers archival data on the advances-declines ratio both on a monthly and daily basis.
In the last week of October 2008, the capitulation phase of the GFC-induced bear market, the advances declines ratio on NSE fell to an abysmal 0.07. 1167 stocks on NSE fell that day, while just 81 managed to hold their head above water.
In the second week of March 2020, when selling was climaxing, there were two trading sessions when the advances-declines ratio fell to 0.15. In recent trading sessions, the NSE advances-declines ratio has hovered at 0.3-0.4 levels. Watch for a dip below 0.20 to verify if we’re in the end-game.
Of course, after making us all brace for the worst, it is also quite possible that the Indian markets don’t get into a capitulation phase at all for now, and simply keep moving sideways for months.
When valuation bubbles burst, a time correction, where markets test investors by staying range-bound for a long spell and not breaking out in either direction, is as much of a possibility as a price-based correction.
This is why it is best not to wait interminably in the hope of catching stocks at a capitulation phase. Deploy part of your cash whenever you find the stocks you want to own at attractive levels, while keeping some powder dry for that capitulation phase. This will ensure that you don’t lose out on buying opportunities, even if the mouth-watering opportunities provided by capitulation prove elusive.
15 thoughts on “When the last bull throws in the towel: Are we at market capitulation?”
Interesting set of indicators that correlated with market bottoms. Loved reading this. Also the comments 🙂
Lots of good indicator, but dollar index was not there, some historical data on this would be appreciated.
also inspite of FII pull out the USD/INR pair is strong, with no signs of panic.
As per one of your early articles,on MFs it’s better to SIP, than wait for a DIP.
Though people have given favourable comments, I view the article as neither here nor there. It is telling you everything except the answer to the question “Are we at market Capitulation ? ” Have the markets bottomed out ? It is usual and classic that investors will be imaginative and speculative and go on buying shares on such recommendations all those shares that have had a significant fall. BUT it is classic that you exhaust all your investible money and when the market actually Capitulates at that time you have no money to invest. Yes, actual bottom toh warren buffet ka dada bhi nahi bataa sakta.
But Madam, as per you, if Zero is the bottom, then on a scale of 1 to 10, where are we ?? It was an enjoyable read but its like telling you what not to do without actually providing any insight on what to actually do..
The Caveat is the best part
Hello Sir, If you will kindly allow me, I think Aarati has peeled the banana enough. Rest is an investor’s job 🙂 🙂
Sniff Sniff !!
Smelling Wisdom 🙂
Great article !
Great Article. Was a bit difficult holding the dates in mind as we read through the article.
A picture is worth a thousand words. Perhaps, you could have a line graph of the nifty with vertical lines at the bottom dates and a callout label at capitulation points with the value of Advance/decline, vix, sip inflows etc called out.
Thank you, shall keep in mind for future!
Hi Aarati … Very informative article on Market Capitulation. It does make more sense and provides better understandings when read along with Historical line chart of Nifty 50 and historical data on ViX open simultaneously.
Can you let us know where can we locate quarterly GDP numbers of India and market capitalization to work out Buffet Indicator? Thanks in advance.
Try rbi dbie for GDP data and bse for mcap. Thank you
Brilliant. Very useful. Thanks ma’am
One more difference between the 2000 dotcom crash, 2008 GFC crash and current meltdown is how much fixed return investments are returning. If I am not mistaken the debt returns atleast during 2008-09 were in high single digits for FD’s and PPF. Given current returns in debt being low, are people more inclined to wait in equities rather than redeem and shift to debt. Same might be the case with gold and property as well comparing 2008-09 to now.
One more aspect is the ease of transacting now in equities comparing to 2008-09, wherein opening accounts and buying equities doesnt need visiting MF offices.
Are these the factors that are contributing to continued SIP’s in the wake of the undercurrent were are seeing in world economies and equity markets.
Yes good points there. But also feel that MF investors panic only when past returns turn deep negative…with a 16% correction that hasn’t happened.
Very informative article. Thanks.
Comments are closed.