Prime Q&A: Should you invest in an ETF or an index fund?

Whatsapp share
Tweet it out
Share on FB
Post on LinkedIn

Q: For a long-term investor, is an ETF a better or poorer option compared to index funds? Which is more expensive in the long term? Can one replace your recommendations of index funds (or FoF, like Motilal Oswal Nasdaq 100 FoF) with the corresponding ETF? It’s a little confusing because your Prime Funds and some of your portfolios recommend ICICI Prudential Nifty Next 50 Index fund, but ICICI Prudential Nifty Next 50 ETF is not recommended in Prime ETFs or portfolios. Shouldn’t the performance be same? And what is the impact of tracking error on investor returns?

ETFs vs Index funds

A: The answer to whether an index fund or ETF is better cannot be generalised. There are several factors that go into deciding which is preferable. These factors are the cost of the index fund, the cost of the ETF, and the brokerage charge itself. If you’re running an SIP, the size of the SIP through ETFs will also matter; more the number of SIPs and larger the SIP amount means higher brokerage. And the final factor is the ETF’s liquidity and the extent of deviations between the ETF’s market price and its NAV.

These factors are also why you cannot replace an index fund we recommend with the corresponding ETF. The ETF may not have the liquidity required and may be suffering from high tracking error. Do remember that only an FoF has an ETF as the underlying (or another fund, depending on what type of FoF it is). An index fund invests in an index – i.e., it directly buys the stocks in the required weights and does not invest in the index’s ETF. Consider the ICICI Pru Nifty Next 50 example in the question. The index fund has low tracking error and a history to check this and therefore we have included it. For the ETF, we included the one that met all our criteria; ICICI Pru Next 50 ETF did not.

Where ETFs satisfy the cost and liquidity aspects, we include them in Prime ETFs (also factoring in attractiveness of the index, of course). But your quantum of investment, how long you will be investing, change in expense ratios and such factors will decide what is cost-effective. It is hard to pinpoint any cut-off amount here.

We’d suggest you avoid trying to drill down so deeply into costs and choices; if you have a demat account with competitive brokerage, and the ETF has ample liquidity, you can invest in the ETF. Else, an index fund is the easiest option as it is clean and simple with no fear of supply and price deviation from NAV. And if you find it hard to maintain a portfolio which features both funds and ETFs, stick to index funds.

buy hold sell

See also : Our ratings of the best Index Funds India

Share via Whatsapp
Tweet it out
Share on FB
Post on LinkedIn

More like this

Please note that any specific queries on any of our recommendations will be answered ONLY through email. If you are a subscriber, please mail  Only general queries or discussions will be answered through the comment section of the blog. For full details, please refer to this post – How to communicate with PrimeInvestor.

4 thoughts on “Prime Q&A: Should you invest in an ETF or an index fund?”

  1. Murali Krishnamurthy


    How can one invest in ETF like Motilal Nasdaq 100 ETF and Mirae FANG+ ETF?
    Is it possible to make purchase on Zerodha which is based in India?
    Should we find a US equivalent for Zerodha?

  2. Hello Madam & Sir,
    I think recently some of Index funds increased there expense rations very high ( Tata Index i think charging Expense of 1% ) So it will be prudent to make a compariosn of Index fund as well as ETF charges to arrive at best option based on number for a long term plan

Comments are closed.

Register for FREE!

Gain instant access to more PrimeInvestor articles, researched products, and portfolios

The essence of PrimeInvestor

Register for FREE!

Gain instant access to more PrimeInvestor articles, researched products, and portfolios

Legal Disclaimer : PrimeInvestor Financial Research Pvt Ltd (with brand name PrimeInvestor) is an independent research entity offering research services on personal finance products to customers. We are a SEBI registered Research Analyst (Registration: INH200008653). The content and reports generated by the entity does not constitute or is not intended to constitute an offer to buy or sell, or a solicitation to an offer to buy or sell financial products, units or securities. All content and information are provided on an ‘as is’ basis by PrimeInvestor Financial Research Pvt Ltd. Information herein is believed to be reliable but PrimeInvestor Financial Research Pvt Ltd does not warrant its completeness or accuracy and expressly disclaims all warranties and conditions of any kind, whether express or implied. The services rendered by PrimeInvestor Financial Research Pvt Ltd are on a best-effort basis. PrimeInvestor Financial Research Pvt Ltd does not assure or guarantee the user any minimum or fixed returns. PrimeInvestor Financial Research Pvt Ltd or any of its officers, directors, partners, employees, agents, subsidiaries, affiliates or business associates will not liable for any losses, cost of damage incurred consequent upon relying on investment information, research opinions or advice or any other material/information whatsoever on the web site, reports, mails or notifications issued by PrimeInvestor Financial Research Pvt Ltd or any other agency appointed/authorised by PrimeInvestor Financial Research Pvt Ltd. Use of the above-said information is at the user’s own risk. The user must make his own investment decisions based on his specific investment objective and financial position and using such independent advisors as he believes necessary. All intellectual property rights emerging from this website, blog, and investment solutions are and shall remain with PrimeInvestor Financial Research Pvt Ltd. All material made available is meant for the user’s personal use and such user shall not resell, copy, or redistribute the newsletter or any part of it, or use it for any commercial purpose. PrimeInvestor Financial Research Pvt Ltd, or any of its officers, directors, employees, or subsidiaries have not received any compensation/ benefits whether monetary or in kind, from the AMC, company, government, bank or any other product manufacturer or third party, whose products are the subject of its research or investment information. The performance data quoted represents past performance and does not guarantee future results. Investing in financial products involves risk. Investments are subject to market risk. Please read all related documents carefully. As a condition to accessing the content and website of PrimeInvestor Financial Research Pvt Ltd, you agree to our Terms and Conditions of Use, available here. This service is not directed for access or use by anyone in a country, especially the USA, Canada or the European Union countries, where such use or access is unlawful or which may subject PrimeInvestor Financial Research Pvt Ltd or its affiliates to any registration or licensing requirement.

Aditya Birla Mutual Fund • Axis Mutual Fund  Baroda Mutual Fund BNP Paribas Mutual Fund • BOI AXA Mutual Funds Canara Robeco Mutual Fund • DSP Mutual Fund  • Edelweiss Mutual Fund
Essel Mutual FundFranklin Templeton Mutual FundHDFC Mutual FundHSBC Mutual FundICICI Mutual FundIDBI Mutual FundIDFC Mutual FundIIFL Mutual FundIndiabulls Mutual FundInvesco Mutual FundITI Mutual FundKotak Mahindra Mutual FundL&T Mutual FundLIC Mutual FundMahindra Mutual FundMirae Asset Mutual FundMotilal Oswal Mutual FundNippon India Mutual FundPGIM Mutual FundPPFAS Mutual FundQuant Mutual FundQuantum Mutual FundSahara Mutual FundSBI Mutual FundShriram Mutual FundSundaram Mutual FundTata Mutual FundsTaurus Mutual FundsUnion Mutual FundsUTI Mutual FundsYes Mutual Funds

Equity: Large Cap Funds | Mip Cap Funds | Large And Mid Cap Funds | Small Cap Mutual Funds | Contra Mutual Funds | Dividend Yield | Focused Mutual Funds | Find Top Index Funds | Best Sector Funds | Thematic Mutual Fund | Best Value Mutual Funds | Equity Linked Savings Scheme | Tax Saving Funds

Debt: Banking And PSU Funds | Corporate Bond Funds | Credit Risk Funds Mutual Funds | Dynamic Bond Funds | Floating Rate Funds | Gilt Mutual Funds India | Find Top Liquid Funds In India | Long term debt funds | Low Duration Funds Debt Funds | Medium Duration Debt Funds | Medium To Long Duration Funds | Money Market Debt Funds | Overnight Debt Funds | Short Duration Debt Funds | Ultra Short Term Debt Fund
Hybrid: Aggressive Hybrid Funds | Arbitrage Mutual Funds | Balanced Advantage Mutual Funds | Conservative Hybrid Funds | Dynamic Asset Allocation | Equity Saving Funds | Multi Asset Funds | Multi Asset Allocation
Mutual fund rolling returns by category: Balanced Advantage | Conservative Hybrid Fund | Corporate Bond | Dividend Yield | Dynamic Bond | Equity Linked Savings Scheme | Floating Rate | Index Funds | Large and Midcap fund | Large Cap Fund | Liquid funds | Low Duration | Mid Cap Fund | Multi Cap Fund | Short Duration | Small cap Fund | Solution Oriented – Childrens Fund | Ultra Short Duration

Login to your account