Warren Buffett never fails to recommend it and 90% of US fund managers struggle to beat it. If you’re wondering what this miracle investment is, it’s the US S&P 500 index. Indian investors will soon have the opportunity to buy this US benchmark locally with Motilal Oswal AMC launching an open-end index fund replicating it – The Motilal Oswal S&P 500. The fund will carry a total expense ratio of 1% under the regular plan and 0.5% under the direct plan, with minimum investments of Rs 500.
The NFO opens on April 15, 2020. Should you bite?
What’s in it?
The S&P 500 index is a free-float market cap-weighted index made up of the 500 most liquid large-cap names in the US market. The index covers 82% of US market capitalisation. Nearly $10 trillion of assets globally are benchmarked to it, with index funds valued at $3.4 trillion tracking it. Compared to the Nasdaq 100 or Dow Jones Industrial Average, the S&P 500 offers a much wider coverage of the US market, representing both industrial and technology names across eleven sectors. The index currently features 505 stocks with a total market cap of $22,569 billion.
Compared to Indian indices such as the Nifty50 or even the Nifty500, the US S&P 500 is a more diversified index. Its top sector – Information Technology – is at 25.5%, followed by healthcare (15.4%), financials (11%), communication services (10.7%) and consumer discretionary (9.8%). Its top ten holdings making up a 25.4% weight. India’s Nifty500 features a bigger weight of 32% weight to its top sector financial services and top ten stocks take up a 44% weight.
Source: S&P Down Jones Indices Factsheet, March 2020
Why go overseas?
Most developed market economies are currently going through the wringer, thanks to the COVD outbreak. Even after its GDP estimates are cut sharply for 2020, India may well remain one of the faster growing large economies in a recession-hit world. So, why can’t investors just stick to Indian equities?
Well, there are three reasons for diversifying overseas.
- Creating wealth from stocks is all about capitalising on lucrative business opportunities. When it comes to capturing lucrative opportunities in consumption, capex or financial services, Indian companies (for all their fast growth) account for a tiny speck on the world map. India’s GDP accounts for barely 3% of world GDP. Therefore, if you stick to stocks listed in India, you’re leaving 97% of global economic activity unexplored for wealth creation. The S&P 500 not only gives you exposure to the global economic leader, US, helps you own easily recognisable global names. It features firms with a significant global footprint, with 40% of the aggregate revenues originating outside the US.
- Despite its growth metrics, when crisis hits the Indian stock market gets lumped with all other emerging markets by global investors, who rush to pull out money. Indian market is often among the worst performers during risk-off phases in global markets, with Rupee depreciation adding to the pain. Investing in markets with more stable equities and currencies can help Indian investors cushion their equity portfolios from significant losses during such phases.
- Despite featuring 5000-odd stocks, India’s listed universe lacks the vibrancy and variety that some global markets offer. Indian benchmarks are made up mostly of old-world oil, energy, software and FMCG names, but an increasing proportion of consumer spends in India (Amazon, Swiggy, Makemytrip, Uber et al) are flowing to companies listed overseas. With growth opportunities arising from Indian consumers increasingly appropriated by global firms, it makes sense to look overseas for your stock bets too.
Finally, if you’ve got some obligations or expenses that are dollar-denominated (like a child studying abroad or preparing for a US degree), it makes sense to hedge against Rupee depreciation by holding some of your assets in dollars.
Why the US?
But if the idea behind diversifying overseas is to capture a wider canvas of opportunities, why invest in the US? Why not in international funds investing in other emerging markets, Japan, China or Europe?
Well, there are three reasons why diversifying into US equities is specially rewarding for Indian investors.
Low correlation: One, when crisis hits global markets, the one destination most global investors flock to, is US treasuries and the dollar. Most emerging market equities and currencies behave just like India during such times, offering limited diversification benefit. When you’re building a portfolio, owning un-correlated assets helps you smooth out returns during negative years. The US stock market has historically shown low correlation with the Indian stock market.
A co-relation of more than 0.5 is significant.
Currency hedge: The US dollar (apart from gold) has proved a safe haven asset during periods of global stock market turbulence. For Indians, periods of global turmoil usually see a sharply depreciating Rupee. Holding dollar-denominated US equities at such times shields your portfolio from sharp downside.
Diversifying into dollar-denominated assets also adds to your returns and helps you gain from Rupee depreciation. The Indian Rupee has depreciated steadily (losing 3-4% a year) against the US dollar for the last three decades. For example, between early March 1999 and 2020, the S&P 500 grew 4.9 times in US dollar terms but grew a whopping 8.6 times in Rupees.
Catchment for innovative companies: As the go-to market for global investors, US exchanges attract some of the most nimble and innovative companies in the world. This makes it one of the resilient markets post-crisis. Though the epicentre of the global financial crisis was in the US, the US economy (prior to the COVID outbreak) was among the first to recover from it, while Europe and Japan were still struggling.
It is the combination of all these three factors that have helped the US S&P 500 deliver much better returns to Indian investors (when translated into Rupees) than the local Nifty500 over the last ten years.
The risks
While diversifying into the US markets has proved a good bet for Indian investors in the past, what could go wrong with this bet?
Well, the US market’s strong outperformance of the Indian market can reverse if US stocks enter a long bear phase, or if the dollar reverses direction after its long rally.
On the first risk, the US economy has certainly been hit harder by the COVID outbreak (going by numbers so far) compared to the Indian economy. Given that it is quite difficult to predict either the COVID trajectory or recovery from it, it is best that investors base their decisions to invest in US markets on stock valuations.
From a valuation perspective, the S&P 500 is today quite expensive relative to its historical levels. On April 13, 2020, the price-earnings ratio of the US S&P 500 based on trailing 12-month earnings was at 21.2 times. Its forward PE was 18.8 times. The latter is significantly higher than the ten-year average of 15 times. The forward PE ratio had corrected to about 14 times a few weeks ago when the S&P 500 had corrected, but the bounce-back since then has restored it to relatively expensive levels.
The valuations may be higher than those numbers indicate because earnings of S&P 500 companies, after growing at a 13% CAGR between CY15 and CY19 have flatlined in the last couple of quarters and are expected to decline by double-digits in CY20, as a result of the COVID crisis.
From a currency perspective, the US Fed after leaning towards reducing its debt pile in 2017-18, has gone back to a debt and money-printing binge in recent months to cope with the slowdown/COVID crisis. The US Fed’s new bond purchase program is expected to bloat its balance sheet to over $6 trillion and the government fiscal deficit to over $1 trillion (over 5 % of GDP) in 2020. US’ earlier debt and money-printing binge after the GFC didn’t do its economy or the dollar much harm. But there’s no assurance that this lucky state of affairs will repeat. If US stock markets correct due to expensive valuations and the dollar begins to slide against the Rupee, Indian investors could see their US equity bets weigh on their returns instead of lifting them.
Our take
We recommend the following based on the above analysis.
- Diversifying into US markets makes long-term sense for Indian investors given the attractive companies and likely Rupee depreciation.
- If you are keen to own US stocks, you have two index options in the MF space, S&P 500 and Nasdaq 100. The S&P 500 index tends to outperform most active managers and offers wider coverage than Nasdaq 100. The Nasdaq 100, on the other hand has shown superior performance but higher volatility. If you want to own a more diversified portfolio the S&P 500 is a better option. If you wish to own US for its strength in information technology then the Nasdaq 100 will be worthwhile provided you are willing to cope with its volatility.
- Use US equities purely as a diversifier, restricting your bet to 10-15% of your portfolio.
- Do not expect the Motilal Oswal S&P 500 to improve your portfolio returns over the next one or two years. It is intended to improve long-term risk-reward.
- Given immediate downside risks to US stocks, use the SIP route to invest in the Motilal Oswal S&P 500 Fund. If you are investing now, make sure you follow it up with SIPs.
62 thoughts on “Should you invest in the Motilal Oswal S&P 500 Index Fund?”
What is difference between index fund , fund of funds and etf . For nifty fifty ,nifty next fifty , nasdaq 100 and S and P 500 which one is a better option index fund or fof or etf and which are the schemes available for each one of them ? Please help me understand. .
Hello sir,
You can refer to Prime Funds and Prime ETFs for recommendations on which index fund/ETFs to buy. If you want a portfolio built with passive funds, you can check the Passive Portfolio in Prime Portfolios. In these, we’ve picked funds and ETFs after considering tracking error, volumes, expenses etc.
Thanks,
Bhavana
What if one has Franklin India feeder – Franklin US Opportunities Fund in the Portfolio. Should one replace with MOSL S&P 500 or continue with Franklin or have both? (especially when expense ratios are also more or less same). Thanks!
The exepnse ratio is marginally higher for the Franklin fund. It will entirely be your call on whether you want a pasive approach or active approach to investing. If you ask me whether you should go with index funds or with active funds in India, it is a slightly easier answer as we have enough active funds that can still beat the inddex. In the US, active funds that beat the index are fewer. Also, while 5 year returns look alike for the index and the Franklin fund, the call should be about cost and whether you prefer a passive strategy.
thanks Vidya
Maam, Can we wait to get more clarity on the expense ratio, tracking error etc which is not known in the NFO period especially when one is invested in say PPFAS ?
If there is something you should wait for, it should be your view on whether S&P 500 is expensive now and needs to correct or it is ok. Expense ratio won’t change much except with AUM. As for tracking error, it will be tough to figure given that the index will be in dollar and the fund in INR. We won’t have running rupee converted index value (Unless somebody provides it). So the returns over time will always vary (in favour of the indian investment, if rupee depreciates). Thanks, Vidya
Please explain if S&P 500 INDEX FUND will be a better choice than ICICI US BLUECHIP or Nippon us opportunities fund.
That’s hard to predict. But with the S&P 500 fund you won’t have to worry about fund manager changes, or the stock selection outperforming the market. The majority of active US funds have lagged S&P 500 in the last ten years.
Will the MO S&P 500 Index Fund be treated like a debt fund for the capital gains taxation purpose since the constituent stocks are all listed in the US ?
Yes it will be treated like a debt fund for taxation.
Thanks for this wonderful article. I remember that I got into to Mutual funds around 2007 by reading your articles.
It’s there any Indian fund which tracks Nasdaq 100?
Thanks
Yes Motilal Oswal also runs a fund of funds that tracks Nasdaq 100.
Is this FoF or direct Index fund?
It is an index fund. Vidya
Article is well researched, written, thanks Aarati!
One question is, isn’t a 0.5% expense ratio high for an index fund?
Dear Prime
I wud appreciate if u cud also include tax treatment of this ETF in India for that wud make a difference in our investment decision.
This is an open end index fund not ETF. It will be treated like a debt fund for taxation with LTCG after 3 years with indexation and STCG at your slab rate before 3 years.
Dont you think this is a huge differentiator for Indian investors when it comes to the cost of investing. If you are investing in the Indian Index Fund (ETF or Index Mutual Funds), the taxation is as per the current equity taxation rules.
However, if opted this fund, because of your taxation, you may end up in adding more expenses in the form of tax.
Kindly advise.
So debt funds don’t have equity-like tax. What is their role in the portfolio? Diversification and hedge? Same applies here. It is not either or. thanks, Vidya
Yes it is somewhat high. But as there’s no local alternate investing still makes sense.
Any index not easy to contruct has and remember the cost they have to incur in currency too. Many indian index funds have more expense ratio than this. Vidya
Yes, but it’s an new index fund which reflects S&P 500 but with increase in AUM, the expense ratio will get reduced in future as people tends to believe for diversification purpose mainly. Also, people diversify by only 10 to 15%.
Very good detailed write up. If an investor already have about 12% US exposure through fund like PPLTE, does this new index fund required? Thanks for the above article.
Good question. PPLTEF gives you exposure to US companies but hedges against currency moves. So you get just one of the benefits of US investing. We suggest you add say 5% in this fund.
Nice review. Should we wait to see the performance of this fund for few quarters and then decide?
Hello Sir, thanks. It’s an index fund. So you don’t particularly need to unless youa re worried about whether it is the right time to enter the US. thanks, Vidya
Yes you could. But make sure you don’t wholly miss the market fall!
Hi
Interesting review and the conclusion is very clear for an investor who has no exposure to global equities.
However, if one is already invested (along with a running SIPs) in Motilal Oswal Nasdaq 100 as well as Edelweiss US technology Equity FOF – then what? What makes more sense, should one of them be replaced with S&P 500 OR no action to be taken OR this one to be added without changing asset allocation?
Thanks
Thanks. This is like choosing between a sector fund and a diversified equity fund. The latter offers lower return potential but with far lower risk..Would suggest replacing Edelweiss Tech fund with S&P 500.
Comments are closed.